Swift Certain Fair Resource Center

  • Programs
  • SCF Evaluations
  • Newsroom
  • About
Home
|
Newsroom
|
Contingency Management Programs in Corrections: Another Panacea?
Posted on July 23, 2018 by Kelly Smith

Contingency Management Programs in Corrections: Another Panacea?

Take the case of the latest panacea in community corrections, the famous Hawaii Opportunity Probation With Enforcement (HOPE) which has been touted as a punishing “smarter” strategy (Hawkin & Kleiman, 2009). At the program’s core are graduated sanctions or punishment approach where probationers are informed that violating conditions of their probation will result in “immediate” arrest and jail time and possibly prison time. Fundamentally, HOPE is a program of threats. In the CM literature, threats do not work as they have no immediate consequences. By immediate, we mean within the minute, not an hour or days later which learning theory has proven in about a thousand experimental replications. Furthermore, if there was a literature that revealed threats had validity, a graduated approach to sanctions is also a guarantee for failure which, by the way, also applies to empirically valid punishers (Bonta & Andrews, 2017; Matson & DiLorenzo, 1984). There is an extensive meta-analytic literature that a consequence of the most common threat used in corrections such as serving actual jail/prison time is not a punisher because antisocial behavior is not reduced on the basis of several meta-analyses (for a summary of the meta-analyses, see Gendreau & Goggin, 2014). The HOPE results prove our point. The National Institute of Justice funded study examining more than 1,500 probationers randomly assigned across four sites into a HOPE condition or probation as usual condition found no significant reduction in recidivism (Lattimore et al., 2016). For other skeptical points of view on HOPE, see Duriez, Cullen, and Manchak (2014). Sadly, programs like these are likely to flourish under the current political climate that supports accountability and get-tough ideology.

Posted in Newsroom
Pennsylvania Governor announces prison inmate population drops for fourth consecutive year after record reduction
Developments and Challenges in Probation Practice: Is There a Way Forward for Establishing Effective and Sustainable Probation Systems?

SIGN UP FOR UPDATES

Keep up with the latest from the Swift Certain Fair Resource Center. Subscribe to our newsletter.

Find us

Swift Certain Fair Resource Center New York University 370 Jay Street, 12th Floor Brooklyn, NY 11201 Telephone: (646) 308-0508

E-mail: info@scfcenter.org

New York University Marron Institute of Urban Management
Web Site Notice of Federal Funding and Disclaimer:
This Web site is funded in whole or in part through a grant from the Bureau of Justice Assistance, Office of Justice Programs, U.S. Department of Justice. Neither the U.S. Department of Justice nor any of its components operate, control, are responsible for, or necessarily endorse, this Web site (including, without limitation, its content, technical infrastructure, and policies, and any services or tools provided). SCFCenter.org - Copyright © 2023. All rights reserved.